They’ll tell you what can’t be done and why. Then do it.” – R.A. Heinlein, The Notebooks of Lazarus Long
So a Bloomberg publication runs a pretty positive story on the increase in gun ownership among women, but – being objective journalists – they have to get a soundbite from the opposition, to wit:
Those Americans who have acquired handguns for protection are living with “serious delusions,” says Caroline Brewer, a spokeswoman for the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence. She contends that few are trained rigorously enough to deploy their weapons in the shock and heat of an attack, that they’ll shoot innocent bystanders, that more times than not their firearms will be turned against them.
“To suggest all these guns make the world safer is pure fantasy,” she says.
Really? Let’s look at some “fantasy” from just the past couple of days, shall we?
First up, we have a blog report of a defensive gun use by a woman:
Short version: Cee shot at a home invader, missed, but successfully convinced him to run like hell.
—
Cee’s sleep schedule has been off this week, so she was still awake around 1:3o in the morning, when she heard something at the back door. She thought it might be the furnace making odd noises, so she peeked around that corner, down the hallway with the furnace, laundry room, and back door, and saw the doorknob jiggling.
My brother and I were fast asleep, so she chose to go grab his handgun instead of waking either of us—an excellent decision because, when she got back to the hallway with that firearm, the bad guy’s head was through the door.
—
So, the bad guy’s head was at the bottom of the doorway because he was standing on the ground. When he saw Cee, they stared at each other for what she said felt like forever. It wasn’t too hard to see the dude because, even though the back-porch light wasn’t on, there was a kitchen light shining partly into the hallway.
Then he resumed trying to open the door and climb into the trailer. Apparently, he didn’t notice that she had a handgun at her side. That’s when she shot at him. She’d used Matt’s 9mm only a couple of times before, as it’s a rather-new addition to their little collection, but she didn’t have any trouble flipping off the thumb safety or aiming. The hollow point hit the mostly closed door, about six inches to the right of the bad guy’s head.
He vanished.
Anecdote #1.
PHOENIX – Police say a suspect who was shot in the backyard of a south Phoenix home Monday afternoon has died from his injuries.
Phoenix police Officer James Holmes said the 29-year-old man was taken to the hospital with life-threatening injuries after being shot by a female homeowner.
Holmes said what sounded like a young child called 911 stating that her mother had shot a man at the home near 45th Street and Roeser Road.
—
Holmes said the incident started earlier in the day when the woman saw two males in the backyard around noon.
She called her husband who told her to get out a gun, Holmes said.
Around 3 p.m. the woman saw two males in her backyard again and went out to check.
Holmes said one of the males pulled out a weapon and pointed it at the woman.
She reportedly raised her own weapon and fired at the man, striking him at least once.
Holmes said the suspect’s weapon was recovered at the scene and at this point it looks like a case of self defense.
The woman and the girl were not hurt, Holmes said.
Anecdote #3:
http://cdn.abclocal.go.com/static/flash/embeddedPlayer/swf/otvEmLoader.swf?version=&station=kabc§ion=&mediaId=8459093&cdnRoot=http://cdn.abclocal.go.com&webRoot=http://abclocal.go.com&configPath=/util/&site=
Note that the woman had just purchased her .38 and had never fired it, yet she was able to defend herself against an attacker who continued to try and enter her home after being fired upon.
In none of these cases were the women apparently “rigorously trained” – especially not in the last one. In none of these cases did they shoot innocent bystanders, and in none of these cases were their weapons taken and turned on them. Granted, the plural of anecdote is not data, but would these three women have been better off disarmed? Caroline Brewer, Brady Campaign expert, once again proves Heinlein’s Rule: listen to the “experts,” then do the exact opposite of what they advise. Brewer is the delusional one living a fantasy.
